Baking Easiest Flaky Pie Crust Ever

moldy

Veteran Member
I've baked for a long time, but could never make a decent pie crust. I didn't like spending $3+ for the refrigerated ones, but I did. I tried all the 'expert' recipes - from Cook's Magazine and others - with no success. Finally, I used Mom's recipe. I mean, it didn't have lard or butter, or weird ingredients, so how good could it be? Of course, all her pies were fabulous. Lesson from all this: I should have just listened to Mom.

2 cups flour
1 tsp. salt
1/2 cup oil
1/4 cup + 1 tblsp. ice water or milk

Roll out between wax paper. Makes 2 crusts.
 

Cardinal

Chickministrator
_______________
It's the ice water in combo with the oil. Or lard. Or butter. That is what makes your flakiness.
 

gizbe

Contributing Member
Thanks for the recipe, moldy. I will give it a try next time I make a pie.

My recipe calls for 1/2 cup butter, 1/2 cup lard, 2 1/2 cups cups flour, a dash of salt and ice water. It has always turned out nice and flakey.

I do like the idea of using half the amount of fat that your recipe calls for, too!
 

Signwatcher

Has No Life - Lives on TB
How long do you bake it and at what temp, please and thank you. Sounds like something even I could attempt and succeed at.
 

moldy

Veteran Member
Depends on what kind of pie you're making. I just did a two crust apple and baked it an hour at 425*.
 

Signwatcher

Has No Life - Lives on TB
Oh, I thought you were supposed to pre-cook the crusts before you put the filling in for the final baking. As you can see, I'm not a chef, nor do I play one on Tee Vee. Sara Lee and I were kinda best buds for a while for the holidays. I'm trying to become more self-sufficient in the kitchen. Thanks for the tip, moldy.
 

summerthyme

Administrator
_______________
Signwatcher... some pies do call for prebaking the crust. This is generally called "blind" baking, and you usually either put some dry beans or chains of ball bearings (pricey, but wonderful if you do a lot of this type baking) to keep the empty crust from buckling as it bakes.

In general, these prebaked crusts are used for cream based pies (like a banana cream, for example) and for some custards.

I use a pie crust recipe which I think may have been originally from Martha Stewart, although I never did watch her on TeeVee. It calls for 1/3 cup lard, 1/3 cup butter, 1/4 tsp salt and 2 cups flour. After cutting the fat into the flour and salt mixture, you blend in between 1/3 to 1/2 cup ice water, until the crust dough just holds together. I've adapted it to using just 2/3 cup of butter, unless we've raised hogs and I happen to have lard on hand. The pure butter crust is wonderful!

I probably should mention that I never make just a single crust recipe (the above makes a double crust pie). I triple it, using my KitchenAid mixer, and if I don't need more than one pie at that time, I pat out measured (dividing the dough into 3rds, and then SLIGHTLY "off" halves... the bottom requires a bit more dough than the top crust) balls of dough, then pat them into flattened disks about 1" thick. While doing this, make sure the edges are smooth and aren't cracked. Freeze them in heavy ziploc bags. You can then remove one or two dough "disks" from the freezer, thaw at room temp (or overnight in the fridge) and you'll have "ready to bake and serve" pie crusts.

If you really want to learn more, go to the King Arthur Flour website and start reading!! http://www.kingarthurflour.com/recipes/

If you click on their "learn" section, they have a "complete pie baking guide" among other useful things.

They also sell several really wonderful cookbooks, which, while pricey, are actually textbooks- they explain the hows and whys as well as what to do.

The "trick" to getting flaky, light pie crusts is to handle the dough as little as possible. Use ICY water for mixing the dough, and don't mash the butter into the flour- you want it "cut in" to the flour, so it looks like fine peas or very coarse cornmeal. I personally prefer using a pastry cloth (much easier cleanup, for one thing) and I made my own years back from unbleached 100% cotton duck fabric. Rolling the dough out definitely is a bit of an art... you really want to roll from the center outwards, and turn the dough round 90° after every few strokes with the rolling pin. I'm betting there are some good videos out there, either on YouTube or the King Arthur website.

Summerthyme
 

Signwatcher

Has No Life - Lives on TB
Thank you SO much for the mini-tutorial, Summerthyme. I will have to try this out. I just usually buy or make a graham cracker crust for cream pies. My hubby doesn't like crust. I don't know why. I remember when my Great-grandma would make just the crust and sprinkle sugar on it. It was SO good warm. She would also make tarts with her crusts. I wish the generations past could still be accessed now that I'm an adult. Memories of a 5 year old just don't have the finer details.

Martha Stewart is wonderful! I used to have a recipe for penne pasta from her. I don't have it any more. Lost it somewhere along life's way. I'll have to try Youtube or King Arthur.
 

gizbe

Contributing Member
Moldy, used your pie crust recipe today for Hubbard squash pie. I was very pleased with the result as it was firm yet flakey and was able to roll it nice and thin. I used canola oil but would like to try part olive oil next time.

Thanks again for the recipe.
 
Top