Pests/Ctrl Help! Deer eating my garden

Dinghy

Veteran Member
I’ve read that some people shred Irish Spring soap and sprinkle it around the garden to keep critters away.
 

packyderms_wife

Neither here nor there.
Beauty salon and ask for the hair they cut off of clients, this is the only thing that I know of that works other than really tall fences.
 

Publius

TB Fanatic
T-posts and insulators run wire and buy a livestock fence charger. Once they walk into it they cannot reason with it and it just scares the crap out of them and they stay away and won't even try to jump the fence.
I have use one for years and it works and wife tested when she backed her butt into the wire one day :xpnd:
 
Last edited:

naturallysweet

Has No Life - Lives on TB
For fruit trees, you can put manure around them. Most animals don't like to eat where another pooped.

You can try chunks or shavings of Irish spring soap around other plants.
 

China Connection

TB Fanatic
Want to keep the deer out of your garden? Here's what works. - The ...
https://www.washingtonpost.com/.../want-to-keep-the-deer-out-of-your-garden-heres-w...
Aug 14, 2017 - Walter is a certified hunt hound, and the perfect deer repellent. .... who admit they pee on their garden, or spread soap and human hair to keep ...
Myth or not: Human urine spooks deer | The Daily Caller
https://dailycaller.com/2013/11/27/myth-or-not-human-urine-spooks-deer/

Nov 27, 2013 - By Jeff Johnston, American Hunter. The Myth: Does human urine spook deer? The Smelly Background Many hunters believe that peeing near ...
Things to help keep deer out of your garden - Sports - Log Cabin ...
www.thecabin.net/sports/outdoors/2010-04.../things-help-keep-deer-out-your-garden

Apr 18, 2010 - Some Arkansas gardeners say that urine is a deer deterrent — human urine, dog urine or coyote urine. The latter is available commercially, ...
How to Use Human Urine as an Animal Repellent | Hunker
https://www.hunker.com › ... › Garden & Lawn › Pests, Weeds & Problems

How to Use Human Urine as an Animal Repellent ... Deer love to munch on tender parts of new plants. ... Your urine is most potent first thing in the morning.
 

Vicki

Girls With Guns Member
Stakes inside stakes 2 to 3 feet apart surrounding garden. They won't jump into them.
 

mecoastie

Veteran Member
My father swears by milorganite. Spreads it after every rain storm. He also has an electric fence around the orchard.
 

Chicken Mama

Veteran Member
Soap, hair, urine, etc do NOT work. Only an 8' fence with a strand of barbed wire along the top does. If you plan to continue gardening, bite the bullet and build the fence.
 

Kathy in FL

Administrator
_______________
I’ve read that some people shred Irish Spring soap and sprinkle it around the garden to keep critters away.

Works for me I also keep bags of human hair as well as bags of shed hair from my cat and dog. It isn't a perfect remedy, needs to be reapplied monthly (or weekly for a bad infestation of deer), but like I said works for me in north Florida on our rural land there. Keeps them out of the orchard anyway.
 

West

Senior
Soap, hair, urine, etc do NOT work. Only an 8' fence with a strand of barbed wire along the top does. If you plan to continue gardening, bite the bullet and build the fence.

A good 6 foot fence will work too, if you have at least one good dog. Like a Great Pyrenees-mix Akbash- Anatolian shepherd, etc..inside the first fence. Then another fence to keep the dogs out.
 

fuzzy

Contributing Member
Tried the soap, urine, etc. Nothing worked until I went to a 7' fence with a hotwire around it. This has worked for years now.
 

summerthyme

Administrator
_______________
So much depends on the individual situation and how habituated/ comfortable the deer are around humans. In places where they are heavily hunted, anything that reminds them of humans (hair, soap odor) will scare them away.

In the suburbs, where they aren't hunted and where people actually feed them, it won't do a thing.

Our solution (very rural, heavy hunting pressure) is our farm dogs. The only crops the deer generally bother is the sweet corn and sonetimes the pumpkins. The dogs herd these odd "cows" out of the garden and chase them to our line fence, where they visibly brush their hands off and say, "there! Put them back where they belong" as the deer bound off across the field and the dogs turn back. (Dogs caught chasing deer are liable to be shot, so it's imperative that you train them to *only* keep them out of the gardens or off your property)

Even a small dog will help if you walk him on the perimeter of the garden (if he'll mark his territory around the garden edge, even better!)

The "territory marking" trick often works... carnivore urine (including that of a meat eating human) sprinkled at strategic intervals around the garden edge and on any paths they take to get to it) really can be effective. You can buy predator urine... folk in very rural areas can just have the male members of the family "mark their territory" directly and personally <grin>. In more populated areas, collecting urine in a more private venue, and then sprinkling it in spots using a watering can or whatever, works.

But yes, the only *foolproof* method is a fence. If a 7 foot tall fence is daunting, consider two electric fences (look at www.kencovefence.com to see what's available) 3-4 feet apart will work. They sell "electric netting" which cones attached to its own posts. But just a single strand of polywire (or better, polyrope, or the flat tape they sell) will work...as long as you have two, spaced far enough apart the deer are afraid of getting tangled. Heck, deer hunters who plant food plots in the woods for the deer use the single strands of hot polywire to keep deer out until the plants are well established and deer season is imminent.

And DON'T FEED THEM! That means keeping any compost piles covered, especially if you toss old fruit, apple peels, etc into it.
Good luck!

Summerthyme
 

West

Senior
I feed the deer corn. And put out salt licks and persimmon juice, and my naighbor has a field of turnips and greens for them. :D
 
Top