SCI Scientists say there are 10 types of dog - and it could explain why sheep dogs are excitable yet Shiba Inu are aloof

Melodi

Disaster Cat
Today's non-doomer news is from the UK Daily Mail and is about new discoveries in canine genetics I thought it was rather fun and interesting at the same time - Many good pictures and images at the link. - Melodi

Scientists say there are 10 types of dog - and it could explain why sheep dogs are excitable yet Shiba Inu are aloof​

Researchers in the USA analysed the DNA of over 200 dog breedsScientists say there are 10 types of dog - and it could ex

They found that each breed came from one of ten different genetic lineages
Breeds in each lineage came with unique behaviours useful for specific jobs
By FIONA JACKSON FOR MAILONLINE

PUBLISHED: 16:06, 8 December 2022 | UPDATED: 11:55, 9 December 2022

Have you ever wondered why your Cocker Spaniel loves to sniff so much, or why your Border Collie literally runs circles around you?

Well so have scientists, and a team from the National Human Genome Research Institute in Maryland think they have cracked the genetic code.

By analysing the DNA of over 200 dog breeds, they managed to classify them into ten groups based on their genetic lineage.

Each group also exhibited specific behaviours, and the experts managed to link them to certain genes the dogs share.

By analysing the DNA of over 200 dog breeds, researchers managed to classify them into ten groups based on their genetic lineage


The team first analysed the DNA of 4,000 dogs, coming from over 200 dog breeds. This allowed them to group them by genetic lineage, resulting in ten groups. Next they found behaviours specific to dogs in each of the ten groups, before performing a genome-wide association study to identify the genetic variants responsible for them

The team first analysed the DNA of 4,000 dogs, coming from over 200 dog breeds. This allowed them to group them by genetic lineage, resulting in ten groups. Next they found behaviours specific to dogs in each of the ten groups, before performing a genome-wide association study to identify the genetic variants responsible for them


Domestication of dogs is known to have occurred at least 15,000 years ago, when grey wolves and dogs diverged from an extinct wolf species.

Wolves would live on the outskirts of hunter-gatherer camps feeding off refuse created by the humans, according to Dr Krishna Veeramah from Stony Brook University, who was not involved in this study.

He told MailOnline: 'Those wolves that were tamer and less aggressive would have been more successful at this, and while the humans did not initially gain any kind of benefit from this process, over time they would have developed some kind of symbiotic [mutually beneficial] relationship with these animals, eventually evolving into the dogs we see today.'

Over the years, humans began to selectively breed dogs that were capable of performing specific jobs, eventually resulting in today's breeds.

Senior author Dr Elaine Ostrander said: 'The largest, most successful genetic experiment that humans have ever done is the creation of 350 dog breeds.

'We needed dogs to herd, we needed them to guard, we needed them to help us hunt, and our survival was intimately dependent on that.'


For their study, published today in Cell, the researchers wanted to identify the unique genes humans were unintentionally honing in on that gave dogs their desirable behaviours.

However, some behaviours may also be partially linked to physical features, like long legs or nose, that were also chosen through selective breeding.

'So pinpointing the genetics of canine behaviour can be complicated,' said first author Emily Dutrow.

The team analysed the DNA of 4,000 purebred, mixed-breed, and semi-feral dogs, as well as wild canids, coming from over 200 dog breeds.

Next, they categorised all the breeds into ten groups, each of which shared a major genetic lineage.

It became clear that each of these groups contained breeds historically used for a specific task, like herding livestock, hunting by scent or hunting by sight.

This suggested that breeds within a group shared a common set of genes that resulted in behaviours that made them well suited for their role.

THE TEN GROUPS OF DOGS WITH UNIQUE BEHAVIOURS
Pointer-Spaniel Lineage: Decreased stranger-directed aggression and decreased dog-directed aggression. Historic jobs: many were used as “gun dogs,” aiding hunters by pointing out game, flushing game into the air, etc. Breed examples: Cocker Spaniel, English Springer Spaniel, Irish Setter, German Shorthaired Pointer, Vizsla

Herder Lineage: Very strong positive correlation with non-social fear, which is similar to anxiety-like responses. Historic jobs: protecting or moving livestock, a subset of which do so by herding. Breed examples: Border Collie, Shetland Sheepdog, Pembroke Welsh Corgi, Australian Cattle Dog

Sled Dog Lineage: Moderate predatory instinct and low trainability. Historically used for carrying loads (people, things). Breed examples: Alaskan Malamute, Siberian Husky
Terrier Lineage: Positive correlations with dog-directed fear, aggression, rivalry, non-social fear, and predatory drive. Terrier group breeds have historically been used for vermin control or by hunters to flush prey from hiding places. Breed examples: Jack Russell, Wire Fox Terrier, Cairn Terrier, Irish Terrier, Soft Coated Wheaten Terrier, Airedale Terrier

Scent Hound Lineage: Strong negative correlation with trainability. Positive correlations with non-social fear and dog rivalry (familiar dog aggression). These breeds are generally used by hunters to track game, primarily through scent trailing. Breed examples: Bloodhound, English Foxhound, Petit Basset Griffon Vendeen

Retriever Lineage: Low predatory drive. Historic jobs: Gun dogs and water dogs specifically used for retrieving game. Breed examples: Labrador Retriever, Golden Retriever, Chesapeake Bay Retriever

Asian Spitz Lineage: Positive correlation with owner-directed aggression and negative correlation with trainability. This lineage is defined more by geographic origin than by historic working role. The Asian Spitz lineage includes a diverse group of working breeds including hunting dogs and guardians. Breed examples: Chow Chow, Akita, Tibetan Mastiff, Shiba Inu

Sighthound Lineage: Lower energy and excitability. These breeds were historically used for hunting because of their speed (and using “sight” as opposed to scent). Breed examples: Irish Wolfhound, Whippet, Greyhound, Borzoi
African and Middle Eastern Lineage: Breed examples: Saluki, Rhodesian Ridgeback

Dingo Lineage: Breed examples: Dingo, New Guinea Singing Dogs, Highland Wild Dogs


The researchers then surveyed 46,000 owners of purebred dogs within each group to identify their pooches' behavioural tendencies.

For example, terriers, dogs used for catching and killing prey, were frequently reported as having a high prey drive.

Having identified typical behaviours of dogs within each group, the researchers wanted to see if they could identify any specific genes associated with them.

As they demonstrate such a unique and easily definable trait of instinctively rounding up animals, they decided to do this with livestock-herding dogs.

They performed a genome-wide association study on the DNA samples, which identified any genes associated with the herding behaviour.

It was found that the herding dogs exhibited more of a genetic variant associated with 'axon guidance', which helps their nerve cells communicate with their brain.

One of the axon-guiding genes identified in sheepdogs, EPHA5, has also been associated with human ADHD and anxiety-like behaviours in other mammals.

It could thus be linked to the high energy levels and hyper focus of sheep herding breeds like Border Collies.

'The same pathways involved in human neurodiversity are implicated in behavioral differences among dog lineages, indicating that the same genetic toolkit may be used in humans and dogs alike,' said Dr Dutrow.

The herding dogs also had more genes important for developing the areas of the brain involved with interpreting social information and learned fear responses.

Dr Ostrander added: 'After 30 years of trying to understand the genetics of why herding dogs herd, we're finally beginning to unravel the mystery.'
 

WalknTrot

Veteran Member
Interesting article. Their descriptions and categories of behavior/talents are no secret to "dog people" but had to laugh at some because so true. Trainability (or not!). ADHD motivating herders (haha!) with great cross-species communication skills, Aggression (or not) in the different groups and focus of the aggression. Prey drive.

Guess about the only common group listed I've not had much experience (actually avoided!) are the terriers. They have a purpose, but it never much meshed with mine. Maybe because their personalities remind me of cats... :lol:

What little I've had to do with sight-hounds and their like... nice dogs. Ridgebacks I like. Serious dogs though.

Pegged the Asian breeds like Chows to a T, Hounds - to a T, and anybody who's had much experience with Australian Cattle Dogs knows there's more than a little Dingo mixed in somewhere. ;)

Pointers/spaniels are a whole different dog than Retrievers - for sure. I can live/work with pointers. Spaniels - not so much. So different that I'd almost split Pointer/Spaniel.

Retrievers are easy - except for Chessies, and from what I've read recently, there is a small but growing movement of concerned, responsible Chessie people who are trying to breed out that hard-headed trait that has traditionally called for the regular and timely application of a 2x4 to maintain civility. Keep the same amazing physical toughness, but tone down the errrm......"personality problems".

Notice that they didn't list German Shepherd (&types), Dobermans or Rotties. Wonder if their genetics cross a couple different groups. GSD must be mostly herding, Dobs and Rotties background more mixed across herder/gun dog/terrier. Weird not to mention, since they are popular breeds.

The little video of the Golden was cute. You knew exactly what she was thinking. Guess we don't often consciously register the many expressions flashing across our dog's faces. They are too close to human.
 
Last edited:

Pebbles

Veteran Member
Thanks Melodi, interesting article. We have border collies and a lab. It never gets old to watch our border collies exhibit their genetic drive to herd our horses. It takes next to nothing to train the dogs how and where to move the horses. The lab tries to copy the BC's behavior when herding and driving the horses but you can see the drive is just not there, she doesn't understand their focus and actions.
 

Shep

Contributing Member
Interesting article. Their descriptions and categories of behavior/talents are no secret to "dog people" but had to laugh at some because so true. Trainability (or not!). ADHD motivating herders (haha!) with great cross-species communication skills, Aggression (or not) in the different groups and focus of the aggression. Prey drive.

Guess about the only common group listed I've not had much experience (actually avoided!) are the terriers. They have a purpose, but it never much mesh with mine. Maybe because their personalities remind me of cats... :lol:

What little I've had to do with sight-hounds and their like... nice dogs. Ridgebacks I like. Serious dogs though.

Pegged the Asian breeds like Chows to a T, Hounds - to a T, and anybody who's had much experience with Australian Cattle Dogs knows there's more than a little Dingo mixed in somewhere. ;)

Pointers/spaniels are a whole different dog than Retrievers - for sure. I can live/work with pointers. Spaniels - not so much. So different that I'd almost split Pointer/Spaniel.

Retrievers are easy - except for Chessies, and from what I've read recently, their is a small but growing movement of concerned, responsible Chessie people who are trying to breed out that hard-headed trait that has traditionally called for the regular and timely application of a 2x4 to maintain civility. Keep the same amazing physical toughness, but tone down the errrm......"personality problems".

Notice that they didn't list German Shepherd (&types), Dobermans or Rotties. Wonder if their genetics cross a couple different groups. GSD must be mostly herding, Dobs and Rotties background more mixed across herder/gun dog/terrier. Weird not to mention, since they are popular breeds.

The little video of the Golden was cute. You knew exactly what she was thinking. Guess we don't often consciously register the many expressions flashing across our dog's faces. They are too close to human.
I’ve had a Chessie. A bit hard headed but one of the best dogs I’ve had! Also had a border collie/ lab mix… great dog (miss him ). We now have a Dobie…. What a change from retrievers! I understand that in the breeding of the Dobie that there was greyhound in the background. That could explain why the LOVE to run
 

bw

Fringe Ranger
Interesting article, but misleading to a degree. They say they've 'discovered' ten types, but it's more accurate to say they decided to lump behaviors into ten groups. They could have lumped behaviors into seven or fifteen. It's purely a product of their creation. Then they found common genes in each group, which is zero surprise.
 

Dux

Veteran Member
And what of poodles? The online resources say they are from Germany and maybe France, working as a gun dog and retriever with an ability to retrieve in water (Pudle is German, meaning puddle ). Their body type looks like a sighthound though, so I imagine they mixed in some of that at some point.
 

bw

Fringe Ranger
This reminds me of the Myers-Briggs scores. They used four binary groupings, and 'discovered' 16 personality types. If they'd used three binary groupings they'd have 'discovered' eight personality types, and if they'd used five they'd have 'discovered' 32. :)
 

bw

Fringe Ranger
Supposedly it's based on DNA, but there has to be a lot of "in-betweeners" or mash-ups.
A lot of those breeds (most?) aren't even close to 200 years old.
They apparently divvied them into trait groups, and then found some DNA commonalities. They didn't trace lineages and end up with similar traits in geographically distant groups. What they did is akin to sorting all the human populations from different continents, and then found that the tall ones coded for a Tall gene. Golly Mr Wizard!
 

Meemur

Voice on the Prairie / FJB!
I'm older, so I have a deeper appreciation for small dogs. Terriers can make really good pets for seniors, especially those from good bloodlines, raised and socialized correctly to avoid the excessive yapping and other bad habits.

Rat terriers have a place on the farms around here. They help with rodent control and don't eat as much as the larger herding breeds.

I wouldn't own a dog over 35 pounds with this incoming recession. Protection from human crud? I shoot pretty well. The dog just needs to warn me that there's a problem, and a little dog can do that as well as a huge one.
 
Interesting article, but misleading to a degree. They say they've 'discovered' ten types, but it's more accurate to say they decided to lump behaviors into ten groups. They could have lumped behaviors into seven or fifteen. It's purely a product of their creation. Then they found common genes in each group, which is zero surprise.
and what about HUMANS?
How many kinds of HUMANS?
 

WalknTrot

Veteran Member
And what of poodles? The online resources say they are from Germany and maybe France, working as a gun dog and retriever with an ability to retrieve in water (Pudle is German, meaning puddle ). Their body type looks like a sighthound though, so I imagine they mixed in some of that at some point.
Yup..from what I've seen, Standard Poodles are firmly in the retriever category. The instinct combined with their blazing intelligence make for an amazing working dog. Of course, like 'em all...the family lines they spring from matters.
 

summerthyme

Administrator
_______________
So basically the different breeds in similar grouping.

Don't they do this at every dog show?

Herding group
Sporting group
Toy group
Working group
Terrier group

Etc.....
Exactly!

It seems all they've done is "found" the genes breeders have been instinctively selecting for since the wolves first came to the fire. Sort of a "duh!" study...

But... it's a good explanation why people should do a lot more research than most do before getting a puppy! For most, a herding bred Border Collie isn't a good fit, for those with cats (or in a suburban neighborhood, with lots of people visiting), Akitas are terrible.

But, of course, there are exceptions to everything!

Summerthyme
 

pauldingbabe

The Great Cat
It was a good article. I hope I didn't detract from that.

I love genetic studies. There is so much knowledge there that we can't even comprehend. At least not yet.
 

packyderms_wife

Neither here nor there.
And what of poodles? The online resources say they are from Germany and maybe France, working as a gun dog and retriever with an ability to retrieve in water (Pudle is German, meaning puddle ). Their body type looks like a sighthound though, so I imagine they mixed in some of that at some point.

And they've also been used as herding dogs as well as guard dogs.
 

Pebbles

Veteran Member
Exactly!

It seems all they've done is "found" the genes breeders have been instinctively selecting for since the wolves first came to the fire. Sort of a "duh!" study...

But... it's a good explanation why people should do a lot more research than most do before getting a puppy! For most, a herding bred Border Collie isn't a good fit, for those with cats (or in a suburban neighborhood, with lots of people visiting), Akitas are terrible.

But, of course, there are exceptions to everything!

Summerthyme
YES!!!! People don't research the type of dogs they get which is a HUGE mistake with border collies (BC). Because BC are striking to look at and they are the "popular" dog right now, so many people get them who have NO CLUE what they are getting into. Honestly, people have become so stupid, their BC's are smarter than they are, and so starts the problems.

Every day I see BC's being rehomed because they are too much for the family, they tear everything up, and nip at the children. They are expected to live in a house or worse yet an apartment and be happy with a walk or two a day.....OH MY STARS!!!! Anyway, just so disgusted with people and the way they treat animals as disposable "things".
 

West

Senior
I'm older, so I have a deeper appreciation for small dogs. Terriers can make really good pets for seniors, especially those from good bloodlines, raised and socialized correctly to avoid the excessive yapping and other bad habits.

Rat terriers have a place on the farms around here. They help with rodent control and don't eat as much as the larger herding breeds.

I wouldn't own a dog over 35 pounds with this incoming recession. Protection from human crud? I shoot pretty well. The dog just needs to warn me that there's a problem, and a little dog can do that as well as a huge one.
Once the SHTF, there will be no problem in getting zombie meat that our big dogs can eat!

:D
 

Seeker22

Has No Life - Lives on TB
YES!!!! People don't research the type of dogs they get which is a HUGE mistake with border collies (BC). Because BC are striking to look at and they are the "popular" dog right now, so many people get them who have NO CLUE what they are getting into. Honestly, people have become so stupid, their BC's are smarter than they are, and so starts the problems.

Every day I see BC's being rehomed because they are too much for the family, they tear everything up, and nip at the children. They are expected to live in a house or worse yet an apartment and be happy with a walk or two a day.....OH MY STARS!!!! Anyway, just so disgusted with people and the way they treat animals as disposable "things".

Ditto for Catahoulas, unfortunately.
 

dawgofwar10

Veteran Member
There are two kinda dogs, big dogs and little dogs. Little dogs take a tad bit more time to devour you, but devour they will!!!!
 

FireDance

TB Fanatic
I still have no idea what our “new” pup is.

She is a terrorist. Like now, it’s pouring down rain - she’s just come in and put rain upon my body.

Her head reminds me of a collie of some type at the muzzle. Then she has what appear to be GSD ears. Straight up. Long body relative to height and curled tail. VERY stubborn, yet very trainable (and the good Lord knows it requires more consistency and persistence than usual.)

Build reminds me of a Pariah dog - long and weird looking. Haha.

pariah dog breed at DuckDuckGo

Help me. Lol.
 

summerthyme

Administrator
_______________
I still have no idea what our “new” pup is.

She is a terrorist. Like now, it’s pouring down rain - she’s just come in and put rain upon my body.

Her head reminds me of a collie of some type at the muzzle. Then she has what appear to be GSD ears. Straight up. Long body relative to height and curled tail. VERY stubborn, yet very trainable (and the good Lord knows it requires more consistency and persistence than usual.)

Build reminds me of a Pariah dog - long and weird looking. Haha.

pariah dog breed at DuckDuckGo

Help me. Lol.
Sounds like she's got some type of cattle dog or Queensland heeler in there...

Summerthyme
 

FireDance

TB Fanatic
Sounds like she's got some type of cattle dog or Queensland heeler in there...

Summerthyme
Hmmm. Quite possible. I say that bc she walks right at the back of our feet and tries to kill me stepping on my shoes. Also extremely mouthy. Does flea biting on both of us and her sister. Poor sissy.
 
Top