Courts Vera Coking - The Woman Who Battled Trump Over the Purchase of Her House

Mixin

Veteran Member
By Associated Press Reporter
Published: 12:18 EST, 31 July 2014 | Updated: 18:26 EST, 31 July 2014

She once called Donald Trump 'a maggot, a cockroach and a crumb.' This week, he remembered her as 'an impossible person.'

The woman who became a folk hero for resisting decades-long efforts by big-name developers like Trump to displace her Atlantic City boardinghouse is now 86 and, at last, has sold.

The 29-room property Vera Coking and her husband bought for $20,000 in 1961 and fought to hold onto went at auction Thursday afternoon for $530,000 plus 10 percent commission, said Joshua Olshin of AuctionAdvisors, which handled the sale. Bidding started at $199,000, priced to sell in Atlantic City's depressed real estate market.

Vera Coking has moved to California to be near her family. And the 29-room property she and her husband bought for $20,000 in 1961 and fought to hold onto is on the auction block Thursday for a $199,000 starting bid. The now-vacant property had been listed for $995,000 since September.

The long-running saga has paralleled the rise and fall of Atlantic City's real estate fortunes, which in recent months imploded. The decision to auction the property was made by Coking's family after they could not find a buyer in recent years, said Oren Klein of AuctionAdvisors, which is handling the sale.

The road to the auction block has been circuitous. Coking first took on Penthouse publisher Bob Guccione in the 1970s, who was reportedly so angered by her refusal to sell that he started building his casino above and around her property.

Trump, who bought Guccione's unfinished project, also tried to buy Coking's building to tear it down and use the land for his Trump Plaza Hotel and Casino. Coking battled with Trump and prevailed in a 1998 state Supreme Court case that blocked attempts by the state to use eminent domain to condemn the property.

Coking's one-woman battle was closely followed in the press and by the people of Atlantic City, where she and her property, sitting defiantly in the shadow of Trump's casino, have been a familiar sight for decades.

Triumphant: In this 1997 file photo Vera Coking walks past Donald Trump, partially obscured against wall at left, in a courtroom hallway at Atlantic County Superior Court. Coking, who became a folk hero for resisting decades-long efforts by developers like Trump to displace her Atlantic City boardinghouse, is now 91 and ready to sell

The modest, three-story clapboard structure is a block from the famous Atlantic City boardwalk and adjacent to the casinos, that like Trump's, have sought to expand their parking facilities or outdoor footprint.

AuctionAdvisors has been stressing the boardinghouse's location just steps from a planned Bass Pro shop and adjacent to an outlet mall that the city advertises as a main attraction. Klein and his associates say that they are confident that Atlantic City will bounce back and that the Coking property is a great buy in one of the last affordable beachfront towns in New Jersey.

Since then, Atlantic City's real estate market and casino businesses have faltered. Trump Plaza may close in September, although Trump himself is largely divested.

The portrait of Coking as a principled holdout is wrong, Trump said, asserting that she had been willing to sell but that they could never agree on a price.

'She could have lived happily ever after in Palm Beach, Florida; instead, she was an impossible person to deal with,' Trump told The Associated Press this week. In addition to millions of dollars, he said, he had offered Coking housing for the rest of her life in one of his properties.

The famously stubborn Trump laughed off a question as to whether he would bid on Coking's home — just to have the last word.

Coking's grandson, Ed Casey, previously told the Press of Atlantic City that it wasn't true his grandmother had once been offered millions. He said she wasn't opposed to selling but was proud to live in and fight for her longtime home.

Messages left at a California listing for Casey were not returned, and Klein said the family had told him they no longer wished to speak publicly about the matter. Information about Coking's health wasn't available.

But back in the day, Coking wasn't afraid to throw a zinger. At the height of their battle in 1998, the 70-year-old Coking said of Trump to the New York Daily News: 'A maggot, a cockroach and a crumb, that's what he is.'

'If Trump's thinking I'm gonna die tomorrow, he's having himself a pipe dream,' she said then. 'I'm gonna be here for a long, long time. I'll stay just to see he's not getting my house. We'll be going to his funeral, you can count on that.'

Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...Atlantic-City-home-530-000.html#ixzz3y4XDxtQc
 

Mixin

Veteran Member
I found a more recent piece from the NYT. I'm only posting snips because most of the article repeats the info above.

It's interesting that the NYT would do a story on something that happened a year ago... digging up old news seems desperate.

The point I want to make here is, according to the article, Trump did not initiate the lawsuit.

The time Donald Trump’s empire took on a stubborn widow — and lost
By Manuel Roig-Franzia September 9, 2015
...
In May 1994, Coking got a letter from the city’s Casino Reinvestment Development Authority offering her $250,000 — a quarter of what Guccione had offered a decade before — and threatening to use eminent domain powers to take control of the property if she didn’t take the deal, according to a summary of the case by the Institute of Justice.

Coking had stared down Guccione. Now she was going to battle with the government, armed with lawyers. But the government had an important ally: Trump, the man whose company would benefit if Coking could be shoved out of her home. Trump’s company took the casino authority’s side in the lawsuit.

A spokeswoman for the casino authority did not respond to an interview request.
...
A mystery bidder paid $583,000 for Coking’s house last summer. The Press of Atlantic City later dug up real estate records revealing that the winning bidder was a subsidiary of a company owned by Carl Icahn, the renowned Wall Street mogul.

With Trump and Coking no longer around to squabble over the house, the wrecking crews moved in.

The storied house by the sea is no more.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/life...cb287e-5660-11e5-b8c9-944725fcd3b9_story.html
 

curlysue

Tomorrow will come
Ok, just so I understand the facts: Guccione owned the property surrounding this woman and started his development. He was having cash flow issues. Trump steps in to finish the project. Make a nice offer she refuses. Trump finishes the project. She gets old, move to California to an assisted living facility and the family puts the place on the market and couldnt even sale it when it was reduced to $199,000. She dies. Family has to settle estate so forced to sell at auction. Icahn buys property at public auction. And exactly why is Trump being painted as a bad person?
 
Ok, just so I understand the facts: Guccione owned the property surrounding this woman and started his development. He was having cash flow issues. Trump steps in to finish the project. Make a nice offer she refuses. Trump finishes the project. She gets old, move to California to an assisted living facility and the family puts the place on the market and couldnt even sale it when it was reduced to $199,000. She dies. Family has to settle estate so forced to sell at auction. Icahn buys property at public auction. And exactly why is Trump being painted as a bad person?

Because people will say or repeat anything that bolsters their own opinion, whether they have true facts or not. This is particularly true of the low-info folks.
 

Mixin

Veteran Member
In his rally today, Trump is all over the Cruz lying ad about Coking/Trump and eminent domain.

He is laying it on the line that anyone who supports the Keystone pipeline is supporting ED.
 

Mixin

Veteran Member
According to the article, Trump offered to buy it. When she would not sell, she received a letter from the city’s Casino Reinvestment Development Authority offering her $250,000 — a quarter of what Guccione had offered a decade before — and threatening to use eminent domain powers to take control of the property if she didn’t take the deal, according to a summary of the case by the Institute of Justice. Trump’s company took the casino authority’s side in the lawsuit.
 

Mixin

Veteran Member
C-Span covered Trump's rally today and took questions afterward. Interestingly, one woman who called in brought up this subject. She said so many people lost money when things went bad but Trump had the foresight to get out while he was still ahead. And that foresight was why she was voting for him.

IMO, Vera Coking was a foolish woman; too hard-headed for her own good. It wasn't like she loved her house too much to leave; she was just a little too greedy. Living there must have been miserable with all that construction going on and all of the casino-related disruptions.

She probably could have played to Trump's soft side and gotten a really good deal. Millions of dollars plus a Trump apartment free for life. She probably could have even gotten limo service.

Instead, she got a little over half a mil for it but she won and that was the most important thing to her.
 

sunny225

Membership Revoked
No, Trump did not try to take through eminent domain.

See, this is so confusing to me! Cause media tries to make it sound like he did. so do some articles & other places.

I figure that Trump HAS used the courts & eminent domain to take people's property though. He has properties all over the place & surely he has come up against someone who didn't want to sell to him.
 
Top